Abstract
The sum of evidence-based nutrition has to be more than a Cochrane-type meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials (RCTs). Most of the evidence base in nutrition is observational, especially cohort studies. RCTs of diet change through to disease outcome are uncommon and the change has usually been addition or removal of only a single food component. Trials with whole diets through to disease outcome are rare and dietary changes made by individuals are unlikely to be an exact copy of the prescription. It is hard to even imagine a trial in which half (randomised) of a large group of middle-aged people agree to avoid vegetables for 5 y and be followed up to see who will develop cancer. Most of the USA's health claims, permitted by the Food and Drug Administration, are not supported by RCTs. But where controlled trials of nutritional change and disease outcome have been achieved, they must be reviewed very carefully. Two Cochrane reviews on diet and cardiovascular disease (CVD), published in the widely read British Medical Journal (BMJ), were criticised after their publication and the conclusions have not been subsequently adopted by expert committees. The first of these reviews was ‘Dietary fat and prevention of CVD: a systematic review’. The second was ‘Systematic review of long term effects of advice to reduce dietary salt in adults’. A critique of these two Cochrane reviews is presented here as a contribution to our discussion of the potential of Cochrane methodology to the reliability of knowledge about diet and disease.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution
Access options
Subscribe to this journal
Receive 12 print issues and online access
$259.00 per year
only $21.58 per issue
Rent or buy this article
Prices vary by article type
from$1.95
to$39.95
Prices may be subject to local taxes which are calculated during checkout
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Beard TC (2004): Salt Matters, A Consumer Guide pp 203–204. Melbourne: Lothian Books.
Gillman MW, Cupples A, Millen BE, Ellison RC & Wolf PA (1997): Inverse association of dietary fat with development of ischaemic stroke in men. JAMA 278, 2145–2150.
Hooper L, Bartlett C, Davey Smith G & Ebrahim S (2002): Systemic review of long term effects of advice to reduce dietary salt in adults. Br. Med. J. 325, 628–632.
Hooper L, Summerbell CD, Higgins JPT, Thompson RL, Capps NE, Davey Smith G, Reimersma RA & Ebrahim S (2001): Dietary fat intake and prevention of cardiovascular disease: systematic review. Br. Med. J. 322, 757–763.
Hu FB, Sacks F & Willett WC (2001): Patient compliance should have been considered (letter). Br. Med. J. 323, 1001.
Joint WHO/FAO Expert Consultation (2003): Diet, Nutrition and the Prevention of Chronic Diseases. WHO Technical Report Series 916. Geneva: WHO.
Keys A, Aravanis C, van Buchem FSP, Blackburn H, Buzina R, Djordjevic BS, Fidanza F, Karvonen MJ, Kimura MJ, Menotti A, Nedeljkovic S, Puddu V & Taylor HL (1981): The diet and all causes death rate in the Seven Countries Study. Lancet 2, 58–61.
Law MR & Wald NJ (2003): Salt needs to be reduced in manufacturing and processed food. Br. Med. J. 326, 223.
MacGregor GA & He FJ (2003): Front cover was highly misleading. Br. Med. J. 326, 222–223.
Mann J, Skeaff M & Truswell S (2001): Conclusion may have been underplayed (letter). Br. Med. J. 323, 1000–1001.
Miettinen M, Turpeinen O, Karvonen MJ, Pekkarinen M, Paavilainen E & Elosuo R (1983): Dietary prevention of coronary heart disease in women: the Finnish Mental Hospital Study. Int. J. Epidemiol. 12, 17–25.
National Health & Medical Research Council (1984): Report of the Working Party on Sodium in the Australian Diet. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service.
Perry IJ (2003): Critical faculties should always be exercised. Br. Med. J. 326, 223.
Reddy WS & Katan MB (2004): Diet, nutrition and the prevention of hypertension and cardiovascular diseases. In Special Issue: Diet, Nutrition and the Prevention of Chronic Diseases: Scientific Background Papers of the Joint WHO/FAO Expert Consultation (Geneva, 28 Jan–1 Feb 2002) Public Health Nutr. 7, 167–186.
Rose GA, Thomson WB & Williams RT (1965): Corn oil treatment of ischaemic heart disease. Br. Med. J. 1, 1531–1533.
Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition (2003): Salt and Health. London: The Stationery Office.
The National Diet–Heart Study (1968): Final report. Circulation 37 and 38 (Suppl 1), 1–428.
Truswell AS (1994): Review of dietary intervention studies: effect on coronary events and total mortality. Aust. N.Z. J. Med. 24, 98–106.
Truswell AS (2001a): Levels and kinds of evidence for nutritional science: a workshop report. Food Aust. 53, 272–276.
Truswell AS (2001b): Levels and kinds of evidence for public health nutrition. Lancet 357, 1061–1062.
Truswell AS (2002): Evidence-based nutrition. Nutr. Diet. 59, 7–8.
Truswell AS (2003): Limit saturated fat and moderate total fat intake. In National Health and Medical Research Council. Dietary Guidelines for Australian Adults pp 107–132. Canberra: Commonwealth Department of Health.
Turpeinen O, Karvonen MJ, Pekkarinen M, Miettinen M, Elosuo R & Paavilainen E (1979): Dietary prevention of coronary heart disease: the Finnish Mental Hospital Study. Int. J. Epidemiol. 8, 99–117.
Watts GF, Lewis B, Brunt JN, Lewis ES, Coltart DJ, Smith LDR, Mann JI & Swan AV (1992): Effects on coronary artery disease of lipid-lowering diet, or diet plus cholestyramine, in the St. Thomas' Atherosclerosis Regression Study (STARS). Lancet 339, 563–569.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
I have no sponsorship or conflict of interest in connection with this publication.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Truswell, A. Some problems with Cochrane reviews of diet and chronic disease. Eur J Clin Nutr 59 (Suppl 1), S150–S154 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.ejcn.1602189
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.ejcn.1602189
Keywords
This article is cited by
-
Association of mushroom consumption with all-cause and cause-specific mortality among American adults: prospective cohort study findings from NHANES III
Nutrition Journal (2021)
-
Cochrane reviews on dietary advice for reducing intakes of fat and salt
European Journal of Clinical Nutrition (2006)