Article Text

PDF

Review: screening instruments had sensitivities of 67–100% and specificities of 53–98% for detecting major depression in older primary care patients
  1. Celia E Wills, RN, PhD
  1. College of Nursing, Michigan State University
 East Lansing, Michigan, USA

    Statistics from Altmetric.com

    
 
 Q What is the accuracy of various screening instruments for detecting depression in older adults in primary care?

    METHODS

    Embedded ImageData sources:

    Medline and PsycINFO (1966 to January 2002); trial registry of the Cochrane Depression, Anxiety and Neurosis Group; US Preventive Services Task Force Guide to Clinical Preventive Services (1996); Agency for Health Care Policy and Research Clinical Practice Guideline on Depression (1993); recent systematic reviews; bibliographies; and peer review.

    Embedded ImageStudy selection and assessment:

    English language studies of depression screening in primary care populations of adults >65 years of age; comparison of instrument with a criterion standard (structured or semistructured diagnostic interviews or independent evaluations by psychiatrists based on DSM-IIIR or DSM-IV, ICD-10, or Research Diagnostic Criteria); and provision of information on diagnostic accuracy (usually sensitivity and specificity). Exclusion criteria: studies done in psychiatric facilities or clinics or those that retrospectively extracted briefer instruments from original versions of an instrument.

    Embedded ImageOutcomes:

    sensitivity and specificity.

    MAIN RESULTS

    18 studies met the inclusion criteria. Meta-analysis was not possible because the studies included multiple screening instruments. 8 different instruments were assessed. The test characteristics of 7 instruments for detecting major depression are summarised in the table. Studies assessing detection of minor or subthreshold depression (Geriatric Depression Scale, Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression scale, and General Health Questionnaire) reported sensitivities of 39–70% and specificities of 72–82%.

    Test characteristics of 7 instruments for detecting major depression in older adults in primary care

    CONCLUSION

    Overall, screening instruments had sensitivities of 67–100% and specificities of 53–98% for detecting major depression in older patients in primary care.

    A modified version of this abstract appears in Evidence-Based Medicine.

    Commentary

    Many screening tools for clinical depression are now available for primary care practice. Watson and Pignone provide a useful and rigorous review of screening tools for older adults in primary care. Consistent with other reviews, the results show wide variations in sensitivity and specificity,1 which are indicators of screening tool accuracy. However, a given screening tool may perform better or worse depending on the population and setting, and even high quality screening tools are not necessarily accurate in populations with a low prevalence of the disorder.2 Screening tools may also lack accuracy for non-major depression, and overall, general screening programmes remain controversial.3 Detection of depression, although necessary, is not the only requirement for effective treatment to occur.4 Adequate treatment of depression in primary care may be impeded by various clinician, patient, structural, and process barriers, and these raise the question of the usefulness of simply implementing screening programmes. Such barriers to adequate treatment should constitute urgent agendas for both future interventions and health services research.

    References

    View Abstract

    Footnotes

    • For correspondence: Dr L C Watson, Geriatric Psychiatry, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC, USA. watso069mc.duke.edu

    • Sources of funding: Robert Wood Johnson Clinical Scholars Program and Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality.

    Request permissions

    If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.