Elderly women described 5 phases of living with change after myocardial infarction
QUESTION: What are elderly women's perceptions about having a myocardial infarction (MI)?
11 women (70–85 y) who were identified in 2 large tertiary care hospitals. Inclusion criteria were age ≥70 years, a first MI, 8 weeks post-MI and had not received coronary artery bypass surgery, ability to speak and read English, ability to reflect on and verbalise perceptions and experiences, and residence within the city limits.
Women participated in unstructured interviews in their homes. Interviews were audiotaped and transcribedverbatim. Content analysis was done and emerging themes were grouped into categories. Pattern coding was done to identify and explain emerging patterns. More comprehensive categories were developed for a more integrated understanding of events. Categories and themes were validated in telephone interviews with participants.
Older women perceived the experience of having an MI as living with change. Throughout their experience, they faced challenges of being in control, managing uncertainty, making sense, being independent, and sheltering others. Having an MI was described as a 5 phase process: searching for a diagnosis, being hit with the reality, discovering the nature of the change, adjusting to the change, and moving on with the change. Not all women completed the process or moved through the phases sequentially. The process was cyclical for women who experienced a recurrence of symptoms. During the first phase, searching for a diagnosis, women became aware that a sudden change had occurred and they attempted to self diagnose and manage their symptoms. Women initially sheltered their family and friends by not seeking advice from them. In the second phase, being hit with the reality, the symptoms were verified, and some women reacted by detaching themselves from the events occurring in the emergency department, whereas others denied the nature of the change. Women reflected back on the diagnosis, their health histories, and related symptoms. During the third phase, discovering the nature of the change, women were admitted to hospital and adopted passive roles to cope with their diagnosis and the unfamiliar hospital environment. Family members sheltered them and monitored their progress. Although discharge teaching helped the women to translate the change, they arrived home with unanswered questions and feelings of uncertainty. In the fourth phase, adjusting to the change, women set limits as to how and when to make lifestyle changes. They depended on their families for support as they strove to regain independence. The fifth phase, moving on with the change, involved accepting the change on a personal level and getting on with life.
The central experience of older women who had a myocardial infarction (MI) was living with change. They described the strategies they used as being in control, managing uncertainty, making sense, being independent, and sheltering others through this process. Elderly women's abilities to live with the physical, cognitive, and emotional changes of having an MI affected their successful passage through this life event.
- Karen Moore Schaefer, RN, DNSc
- Assistant Professor, Department of Nursing Temple University College of Allied Health Professions Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
This study by Sutherland and Jensen uses a qualitative approach to describe the process that elderly women use to manage life after an MI. It contributes to current knowledge by describing the process from the perspective of elderly women, a population not widely included in research until recently. Study findings reveal possible needs of elderly women after an MI and potential implications for nursing practice.
It has been suggested that cardiac care should be sex specific. Several of the women in this study delayed seeking help with their symptoms, indicating that women are still not “tuned into” the notion that they may have heart disease. This suggests that public education about the symptoms experienced by women having an MI has not been universally effective. Additionally, physicians may not recognise the variations of symptoms in women with heart disease. Thus, efforts to educate the public and healthcare providers need to be expanded.
The findings are similar to other studies that have examined women's experiences of heart disease and other chronic illnesses. Morse and Johnson identified similarities in studies examining the illness experience for women after an MI, women having a hysterectomy, and women leaving a psychiatric hospital.1 Several of the experiences such as relinquishing control, making sense, taking charge, and attaining mastery are similar to this study's findings. Schaefer found that women who survived a cardiac event initially denied the importance of the symptoms, but then accepted that they had an MI, accepted the need for change, regained control, and moved on with their lives.2
Interested investigators might consider conducting a systematic review of qualitative studies that have focused on experiences of women with cardiac disease or chronic illness. There may be a process that describes how women manage chronic illness (heart disease) that is applicable to several populations of women. An understanding of this process would help to direct nursing care for these groups.
Source of funding: no external funding.
For correspondence: Dr L Jensen, Faculty of Nursing, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB T6G 2G3, Canada. Fax +1 780 492 2551.